Skip to content
Mainland Software

Free website audit tools, and what they can't tell you

· 3 min read · Kelly

You don’t need to pay for website audit software to find out what’s wrong with your site. The best tools are free, and most of them come from Google. The catch is that they produce a lot of warnings and very little judgment about which ones matter.

Here are the four I’d start with, what each one is for, and what you still won’t know when you’re done.

PageSpeed Insights: how fast it loads

PageSpeed Insights is Google’s speed test. Paste in a URL and you get two things. The top section is real-visitor data, if your site has enough traffic for Google to have collected some. The bottom is a lab test run on a simulated mid-range phone, with a list of suggested fixes.

Test on mobile, not desktop. Mobile is where most small-business traffic comes from, and it’s where slow sites get exposed. If your mobile performance score is under 50, that’s the first thing to fix. I’ve written about what usually causes that.

Google Search Console: what Google sees

Search Console is the one tool on this list that shows you Google’s actual view of your site, not a simulation. It tells you which pages are indexed, which ones aren’t and why, and which searches you’re showing up for.

That last part is the most useful thing a small business can look at. If you’re getting impressions for searches you’d love to win but no clicks, you’re on page two or three. That’s often fixable with better content on a page you already have.

Setting it up means proving you own the site, usually by adding a DNS record. It’s a one-time job.

Lighthouse: the all-round check

Lighthouse is built into Chrome. Open any page, right-click, choose Inspect, then find the Lighthouse tab. It scores four things: performance, accessibility, best practices, and SEO. Each score comes with a list of specific problems.

It’s the same engine PageSpeed Insights uses for its lab test, but running it yourself lets you check pages Google can’t reach yet, like a site that’s still in development.

WAVE: accessibility

WAVE checks whether people using screen readers or keyboard navigation can use your site. It flags images with no description, text that’s hard to read against its background, and form fields with no label. Accessibility problems tend to be SEO problems too, since Google reads your site a lot like a screen reader does.

What none of them tell you

Run all four and you’ll have a long list. Here’s what’s missing from it:

Which problems are worth money. A tool weighs a missing image description the same whether it’s on your homepage or a page nobody visits. Some fixes take five minutes and some mean rebuilding the theme. The tools don’t know your budget.

Whether the site works as a business. No tool checks that your contact form reaches your inbox, that your phone number is right, or that a customer can find your prices.

Whether the words work. A page can score 100 everywhere and still fail to explain what you do or why anyone should pick you.

That gap is why I offer a free audit: I run the same tools, then sort the results into what’s worth fixing and what isn’t, in plain English.